CIRAD-Reduction of Forest Taxation for Certified Concessions with Compensation to States

 

 

Please, download the Document here below:

La fiscalité forestière en Afrique centrale RAPPORT V2 fev 2020.pdf (1.8 MiB)

 

 

The Compensated Reduction of Forest Taxation mechanism (CRTF) only deals with forest taxation, which is mainly made up of three royalties or taxes: the area royalties, the felling tax and the export tax. The hypothesis underlying this study is that responsible forest management certification (FSC or PAFC type) is today one of the best guarantees of compliance with existing regulations, while at the same time encouraging companies not to limit their efforts to legal/administrative requirements in the social and ecological fields. Despite its expansion in tropical areas, FSC certification of natural forests in Central Africa has stagnated since 2014 and declined in 2017-2018 with 1.2 million hectares less. One of the reasons for this slowdown is the increasingly important share taken by Asian markets and other emerging countries in the timber exports of African countries, to the detriment in particular of the European market, which is the most sensitive to certification.

 

The issue:

The "business model" of certification depends on "price premiums", which are not always existing or sufficient. If market incentives are insufficient, incentives could be designed upstream, at the production level. In Central Africa, reducing costs through taxation is one of the only costs items that can be modified by a policy decision. As countries are unlikely to forego revenue without compensation, it will be necessary to compensate them for the revenue shortfall. Reducing costs through fee reductions would not only complement the commercial incentive of certification, but would also potentially attract a new category of concessionaires, namely those whose market outlets are not very sensitive to certification. A coalition of donors could propose agreements to producer countries to compensate national budgets for the reduction of taxation for FSC-certified concessions (or those adopting the new PAFC label). Compensation should be maintained over a minimum period, ideally 7 to 10 years, to allow currently uncertified concessionaires to become certified. The fiscal compensation period would be fixed (and not "à la carte" for each company), with an initial and a closing year, with interested concessionaires having to seize the temporal window of opportunity, otherwise they will lose the potential fiscal benefits of the mechanism.

 

 

Another hypothesis underlying this option is that, once certified, companies will have access to new markets, usually more lucrative, without this being at the expense of their traditional markets. Furthermore, experience shows that in order to achieve certification, and once certified, companies streamline their forest management, which leads to cost savings and improved productivity. A new corporate culture is developing and it is therefore unlikely that companies will revert to their old practices and abandon certification even after the end of tax benefits.

 

Results and recommendations:

While the three countries concerned by the study, Cameroon, Congo and Gabon, have fairly comparable forest areas, forest taxation generates very different levels of revenue. In countries that still have significant volumes of log exports, the majority of revenues are derived from this raw timber export stream. For example, in Cameroon log exports represent 25% of the volume of roundwood equivalent exported, but generate 84% of export tax revenues.Cameroon is characterized by a very high tax burden, both in terms of area royalties and log exports. Conversely, forestry taxation generates relatively little revenue in Gabon, following the log export ban, the disappearance of a genuine felling tax and the absence of export taxes on exported timber. Nevertheless, companies pay significant amounts for parafiscal levies. Congo is in an intermediate position, but the importance of the parafiscal levies that weigh on companies must be stressed.

 

 

Various tax abatement scenarios have been carried out. If donors are willing to finance it, an agreement for a compensated reduction of forest taxation should be sought as a priority with Cameroon. Compensated reductions should be significant, of the order of 50%, in the first two years of the agreement, which would correspond to limited sums since there is only one certified concession, and this situation should change little in the first two years following the introduction of the CRFT measure (time needed for companies to prepare for certification). The rate could then stabilize at 30% for the following years. If the certified area is around 350,000 ha for years 1 and 2, the sum to be compensated will be around €2.44 million (50% cut). A principle of "overcompensation" for the loss of tax revenue for the State could be adopted in order to encourage the government to conclude an agreement.

 

 

For Congo, it seems necessary to know the modalities and the consequences on taxation of the principle of "production sharing" which should be included in the new forestry law. The Ministry in charge of forests indicated that once the law is adopted, a study would be launched to consider the modalities for implementing this measure, so it will be necessary to wait for the conclusions of this study and the law enforcement texts before considering a dialogue on the CRFT mechanism.

 

 

In Gabon too, forest taxation is likely to be modified very soon, justifying waiting to learn about the new tax regime before proposing the mechanism. The principle of differentiating tax rates for certified companies could be adopted in a new tax regime and result in an increase in certain taxes for non-certified companies. While this principle is in line with the incentive logic of the CFRT mechanism, it remains to be seen whether the tax differentiation to be proposed will provide a sufficient incentive for new companies to follow the three already certified companies. If the level of incentive is considered insufficient, the use of the RCF mechanism could be justified. Of course, the implementation of the obligation to certify forest concessions as early as 2022 would render the CFRT mechanism irrelevant. If, however, this measure did not come into force in 2022, but at a later date, the CFRT mechanism could be used in the meantime to facilitate the transition.

 

For more Information, please, download the Document here below:

 

Go back

CBFP News

COVID-19 crisis tells world what Indigenous Peoples have been saying for thousands of years - nationalobserver

COVID-19 and other health endemics are directly connected to climate change and deforestation, according to Indigenous leaders from around the world who gathered on March 13, in New York City, for a panel on Indigenous rights, deforestation and related health endemics.

Read more …

A sustainable global economy must arise once COVID-19 pandemic is reversed, UN chief tells G-20 summit - UN

World leaders at the G-20 virtual summit held on Thursday committed to inject over $5 trillion into the global economy to counteract the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. They will also expand manufacturing capacity to meet the huge and increasing demand for medical supplies, which will be made available at an affordable price and in the shortest possible time, pledged the leading economic powers.

Read more …

Join us in the fight against COVID-19! - INTERHOLCO

Whilst our teams continue to guarantee the best customer service in this evolving situation, our thoughts are with the families of those who are suffering and our deepest gratitude goes to the medical personnel who watch over them, at great personal risk. We are thinking outside the box to collect extra funds, critical to prevention and mitigation activities in the Northern part of the Republic of Congo. In a remote area, 1000 km away from the capital Brazzaville, our medical facilities already serve on a daily basis a population of 16’000 inhabitants, including indigenous people.

Read more …

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) update - iucncongress2020

In light of recent developments in France linked to the coronavirus disease (COVID-19), IUCN and the Government of France are in close discussion about the impacts on the IUCN World Conservation Congress 2020. Together, we are carefully considering any decisions that might need to be taken.​​​​

Read more …

New dates and venue for critical UN Biodiversity Convention meetings, dates for UN Biodiversity Conference 2020 to be adjusted – CBD

The twenty-fourth meeting of the Subsidiary Body on Scientific, Technical and Technological Advice (SBSTTA-24) will now be held 25 to 30 August 2020; and the third meeting of the Subsidiary Body on Implementation (SBI-3) will take place 1 to 6 September 2020. Both meetings will be held in Ottawa, Canada.

Read more …

China’s Belt and Road Initiative could pose increased risk to endangered wildlife, EIA warns UK MPs - EIA

The global spread of China’s controversial Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) brings with it increased risks of endangered wildlife consumption and illegal wildlife trade, UK politicians were warned. At an event organised by the All-Party Parliamentary China Group in Parliament yesterday (11 March), EIA Wildlife Campaigner and China Specialist Aron White cautioned that the international proliferation of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) – touted as a pillar of the BRI – poses potential risks for biodiversity around the world.

Read more …

Differentiated evolution of the tropical timber trade in 2019 – COMMODAFRICA – ATIBT

The 16 March 2020 article on the COMMODAFRICA website shows that log imports into China have decreased and that sawn timber imports into the European Union are increasing for the second consecutive year.

Read more …

Atibt- Timber sector in the DRC: Study on the state of play of the stakeholders

As part of the implementation of the FLEGT-REDD CERTIFICATION projects set up by the ATIBT and financed by the European Union, the FFEM and the KfW, the Federation of Timber Industrialists, in abbreviation FIB, conducted a study on the state of play of the actors of the forest and wood sector in the DRC.

Read more …

CBFP News Archive

2020