International treaties threaten affordability of climate action: new report IIED

A new IIED report shows how key international legal measures could risk an increase in the cost of shifting to green energy and tackling climate change.

 

A complex set of international legal measures protecting the fossil fuel industry risks significantly increasing the cost of moving to green energy and tackling climate change, a new IIED report has revealed.

The ‘Raising the cost of climate action? Investor-state dispute settlement and compensation for stranded fossil fuel assets’ study is the first to quantify the proportion and value of the fossil fuel industry and associated infrastructure that is protected by international treaties that include provisions for investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS).

 

ISDS could require governments – effectively the country’s taxpayers – to pay large compensation sums to fossil fuel companies.

And with previous research having shown that the value of potential stranded assets in the power sector alone is nearly US$2 trillion, and valued at $3-7 trillion for oil and gas reserves, the cost could be substantial.

 

IIED director Andrew Norton said: “Ending dependence on fossil fuels is crucial to being able to tackle climate change, and our research shows that rethinking investor-state dispute settlement is a key part of making that possible.

 

“It is vital that people are not made to bear the costs of compensating fossil fuel companies and that the state instead invests in clean, green alternatives.”

Obscure but powerful

 

There are more than 2,600 bilateral investment treaties and preferential trade agreements that protect foreign investors’ assets.

And while these treaties may be obscure, they are powerful; ISDS enables foreign investors, including shareholders, to sue states over conduct they believe breaches international investment protection rules, such as vital action to cut emissions.

 

Examples could include the early retirement of coal-fired power stations and oil refineries, not exploiting coal, oil and gas reserves, and scrapping pipelines and other fossil fuel transport infrastructure.

 

These are the measures that governments need to take to fulfil the climate commitments they have signed up to under the Paris Agreement.

 

The report was released to coincide with the latest meeting by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law’s working group on investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) reform, taking place from 5-9 October. The working group was set up to review possible reforms to ISDS, particularly procedures for settling disputes between investors and states.

 

And in the study, authors Kyla Tienhaara, Canada research chair in economy and environment at Queen’s University, and IIED’s Lorenzo Cotula, urge a range of measures to address ISDS.

 

These include terminating old treaties, developing innovative drafting approaches for any new treaties and radically modernising the Energy Charter Treaty, which plays a significant role in protecting foreign-owned coal power plant assets.

 

Coal-fired power station focus

To date, huge pay-outs have been made based on ISDS tribunals’ estimation of what an investor could have earned over an installation’s lifetime. However, these projections often do not consider the volatility of fossil fuel prices as renewables have become more competitive and as other factors have impacted the market.

 

‘Raising the cost of climate action?’ includes a focus on coal-fired power stations. ISDS protects most of the world’s 257 foreign-owned coal plants, which must be retired early in order to put the planet on track to keep temperature rise below 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels.

 

In Indonesia, one example highlighted by the report, the estimated value of 12 coal-fired power stations protected by ISDS could be up to $7.9 billion. The cost of ISDS compensation could be even greater.  

 

Read more...

 

For more Information, please, download the Report here below:

 

Go back

Partners News

Final Reports: United Nations Biodiversity Summit

The Summit focused on the theme “Urgent Action on Biodiversity for Sustainable Development,” to highlight the urgency of action at the highest levels in support of a post-2020 GBF that contributes to the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (2030 Agenda) and places the global community on a path towards realizing the 2050 Vision for Biodiversity, “Living in harmony with nature.”

The Evolving War on Illegal Wildlife Trade - IISD

Illegal trafficking and unsustainable trade in wildlife are causing unprecedented declines in some species. They can also potentially lead to the spread of zoonoses, such as SARS-CoV-2, which causes COVID-19. While the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora has been in force since 1975, there are growing calls to build a stand-alone international instrument to address illegal wildlife trade and crime.

How to Make Climate Risk Insurance Better Meet the Needs of the Vulnerable? – IISD

When climate risk insurance (CRI) schemes first started gaining popularity ten years ago, many believed they would be a solid solution to help vulnerable communities financially manage natural hazards and adapt to climate change. However, over the past decade implementers have learned that changes to existing approaches are required to better meet the needs of the target populations.

Leaders Stress Importance of Transparency and Trust in Pandemic Recovery Efforts – IISD

“Spend what you need to, but you need to keep the receipts.” Speaker after speaker elaborated on this theme and its objectives during a discussion organized by the Open Government Partnership on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly’s 75th session. Principles such as transparency, accountability, participation, trust, communication, and inclusion were highlighted as critical components for the effective governance of stimulus packages and efforts to respond to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Brief Explores the Role of the Governance in Protecting Global Biodiversity –IISD

A policy brief from the International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) emphasizes that reversing the alarming rate of biodiversity loss requires a significant policy shift away from business as usual. The coming decade is of utmost importance for global governance of biodiversity, the authors stress.

UNCCD meets with LAC representatives to discuss future cooperation in land restoration – unccd

The UNCCD Executive Secretary Mr. Ibrahim Thiaw held a virtual meeting with the Minister of Environment and Natural Resources of Nicaragua Ms. Sumaya  Castillo, the Executive Secretary of the Central American Commission for Environment and Development (CCAD) Mr. Salvador Nieto, and the special envoy for LAC, Mr. Edgar Gutierrez, to discuss a future cooperation cooperation agreement and review land restoration activities in the region.

UNCCD and the IIASA enter partnership to support science, technology and innovation – unccd

Bonn, Germany/Laxenburg Austria – UNCCD and the International institute of applied systems analysis (IIASA) signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) on 30 September 2020 to promote the application of integrated system analyses in support of science, technology and UNCCD implementation. This MoU builds on shared priorities and strategic vision of both institutions to advance transformational changes that help achieve sustainable development goals, in particularly SDG15.3 on Land degradation Neutrality.

National workshop on certification and traceability in the DRC in Kinshasa. – ATIBT

This workshop was organized by the Federation of Timber Manufacturers (FIB) in collaboration with ATIBT through the FLEGT REDD, FLEGT IP and FLEGT certification projects, namely "Improving the integration of third party verified certification into FLEGT-REDD processes", projects awarded to ATIBT aimed at improving the legal level of companies through professional associations, project partners, and through the promotion of third party verified certification, to prepare them for the implementation of FLEGT VPAs.

Tree planting is critical for sustainable future but can’t fix climate change on its own – CIFOR

Around 40 kilometers south-west of the Ethiopian capital, Addis Ababa, native and exotic trees stand side by side on 8 hectares of the Suba Forest. Surrounded by tall junipers and idyllic mountains, this group of seed orchards is just one of many that serve as incubators for the country’s impressive landscape restoration efforts.

UN Biodiversity Summit Supports 2030 Agenda-aligned Post-2020 Framework –IISD

The first UN Biodiversity Summit highlighted the urgency of action at the highest levels in support of a post-2020 global biodiversity framework that contributes to the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and places the global community on a path towards “living in harmony with nature” – the 2050 Vision for Biodiversity.

FAO Director-General calls for transformational change in the way we manage our forests and food systems that depend on them – FAO

5 October 2020, Rome - Transformational change is needed in the way we manage our forests and their biodiversity, produce and consume our foods and interact with nature, if we want to build back better after the COVID-19 pandemic and achieve the Sustainable Development Goals. This was the key message of a speech delivered today by FAO Director-General QU Dongyu at the 25th session of the Committee on Forestry (COFO).

The status of the forest elephant in the world heritage Dja Faunal Reserve, Cameroon

Our forest elephant dung-based distance-sampling survey of the 5,260 km2 World Heritage Dja Faunal Reserve (DFR) in Cameroon systematically covered 298.2 km of line transects with a further 1,681.4 km covered as recces. The population estimates of 0.042 individuals/km2 (CV: 19.4%; 95% CI: 0.029–0.061) and 219 individuals (95% CI: 150–319) confirmed a significant decline over recent years.

Call for Expression of Interest for the selection of a Development Bank in charge of opening and managing a "Blue Fund for the Congo Basin" financing line. – CBCC

The Congo Basin Climate Commission (CBCC) is launching a Call for Expression of Interest (CEI) for the selection of a Development Bank in charge of opening and managing a "Blue Fund for the Congo Basin" financing line.

FLEGT-IP and FLEGT-REDD Project Workshop SPIB - ATIBT "Traceability and Forest Certification of Wood" - ATIBT

On Tuesday, September 22, 2020 was held in Abidjan, from 9:00 am to 6:00 pm at the Palm Club Hotel, the workshop on Traceability and Certification, organized by ATIBT and SPIB, as part of the implementation of activities of the FLEGT-IP and FLEGT-REDD Project in Côte d'Ivoire.